Skip to Content

Blog

'When David Heard' with the Los Angeles Master Chorale

May 6, 2008 at 5:50 pm UTC

Sunday night the Los Angeles Master Chorale performed my When David Heard on a concert featuring music of L.A. composers, or composers with a Los Angeles connection. Except for Gorecki (who couldn’t be there) each of the composers whose music was featured was actually in the audience. Steven Stuckey, Esa Pekka Salonen, Morten Lauridsen, David O (with and incredibly fresh and exciting premiere), and yours truly.

Grant Gershon conducted the entire concert beautifully; so many colors and subtle nuances from the choir. And the singers are just incredible, truly a world-class ensemble, made all the better by the otherworldly acoustic in Disney Hall.

I won’t say much about When David Heard except this: it is just excruciating for me to hear it. Even now, nine years after I wrote it, the pain in those notes is still right there, right at the surface, as real and visceral as it ever was. Worse yet is when I’m not conducting, sitting in the audience with nothing to do but agonize over every pause, every chord. I’m thrilled that they performed the piece, and I’m happy that the audience seemed to connect with it. But I was dying through the entire thing, silently begging Grant to go faster so that it would be over as quickly as possible.

One more thought about the concert: Morten Lauridsen is a master. (I’m about to use a bunch of italics, because I feel so passionately about this). I’m not talking about musical content, or text settings, or similarities to his other pieces. (There is much debate over all of that, but for the record, I’m a huge fan of his, both as a composer and as a person). I’m talking about the orchestration of the choir, the ‘voice-estration’ if you will, his knowledge of the human voice and how to use it in an ensemble setting. His pieces just sound gorgeous. Lush, and warm, like honey, or butter, or cream. I think that part of his extraordinary success – and I attribute this same quality to the success I’ve had with October, my work for symphonic winds – is that it just sounds so good, and so many different choirs, both good and not-so-good, can pick it up and sound good. I’ve just ordered everything Maestro Lauridsen has composed, and I’m going to go through the scores with a fine-toothed comb and try to learn what it is he does that makes the choir open up and simply blossom.

  • Preston

    If anyone can crack it open-you can, but good luck, because you are up there, you and Lauridsen are the best…Wow, really, everyone i talk to about composers, you and him come up!

  • cristian reyes

    it was great meeting you at the concert the other day! your music is absolutely brilliant, and when david heard is no exception. It's funny you mention that it is excruciating for you to hear "when david heard" because when I hear it, i feel the EXACT same way. I cringe at the chords and the "crying out" from the choir. In fact the choir literally sounds like they're crying, but through singing; quite an amazing feat to convey something like that through music. It is so amazing how well you put this piece together, just hearing the agony in the singers voices as they sing. I get goosebumps every time i hear that song. Thanx for making great music and being so friendly to me when i met you! You're great. Never stop making beautiful music because it has such a positive effect on people, including me.

  • Tommy H.

    That's great stuff, Eric. I love that,"now how did he DO that??" moment. It always inspires me and I always learn something that I didn't think was possible to achieve. Very cool! Also, I listened to the "sneak peek" of the David O. Piece on the master chorale website and got shivers just from that. how cool that he included the names from that cemetery.

    See you in Pasadena!

    Tommy

  • Tessy

    When David Heard always gives me shivers, it's so beautiful and perfectly emotional (not overly dramatic, and not held back). I like how you've also given the piece a very human touch of sorrow. When I first heard the piece on one of your cds, I remember my heart being torn out and I just cried. It was so powerful.

    ps – I think you have described Lauridsen's music perfectly.:) Good luck with your musical search!

  • http://www.straightaheadjazz.blogspot.com Matthew

    What techniques did you use to create that pain and agony?

  • Luke

    OO, I just got the score for Lux Aeternum, it's so amazing and true what you described. Yet, wow, he takes the bass part up very high (G above staff in bass clef O.O).. at least high for my voice. Yet, he uses some moderate extremes on all of the voices, which is sooo neat though.

  • Gabby

    I just got a cd and a piece of music of Lauridsen's today…i just started becoming obsessed with his stuff and it's beautiful. When David Heard is one of my favorite pieces, the first time I heard it I was completely blown away, the silences balance out the pain in the piece flawlessly. I also wrote about your "i thank You God…" for a music class! I wrote about how it solidified my faith, and how I believe faith and music go hand in hand. Good luck!
    Gabby

  • Tessy

    Yeah, how did you get that feeling of agony? By the way, I just listened to it tonight and…*sigh* I am still stunned by it…wow.

  • Rob

    Eric, I've heard different rumors regarding the circumstances that brought When David Heard into being. I think you wrote it originally for BYU, is that correct?

  • Sarah

    When my choir say Lux Aeterna last year, I was stunned by it's beauty. I did not get the chance to sing the entire thing with my choir when they went to Carnegie Hall where they also premiered Arise Shine!, but I will never forget the feeling of singing O Nata Lux. I'm graduating soon and I feel so grateful to my teacher for teaching us your beautiful piece "Sleep" and introducing me to all of your music, Lauridsen's "Lux Aeterna", Dan Forrest's "Arise Shine!", Handel's "Dixit Dominus" and Moses Hogan's "Elijah Rock."

    All the music I have sung have inspired me and I couldn't be more grateful to him for it. "When David Heard" is probably one of the most powerful choral works I've heard. The emotion and the power of the chords each part sings just takes my breath away. I get the goosebumps everytime I listen to it. You're music inspires me to live up to each and every note that comes out of my mouth and I thank you for that.

  • http://www.myspace.com/marcusmcleod Marcus McLeod

    I think it'd be interesting for you and Maestro Lauridsen to get together, decide on a poem, passage, or some written segment and each compose a song to it. I think it'd be marvelous to hear the similarities and interpretations of the same passage/poem/verse. And, of course, they'd both sound amazing because the two of you are both unbelievably talented.

    I'd really love to see if that would ever happen. Just another one of my musical dreams, I suppose.

    I ordered the music for When David Heard because I was considering getting a 'small' group (how small could it be? It divides to, what? 17 parts?) together to perform it. It moves me to tears every time. I'm even listening to the BYU singers recording of it as I type this. And it's almost to the part that always makes me cry. The alto's little solo part. You know the one.

    I'm really excited for the potential of a new CD in the future. Keep us posted :)

  • Wendell Clarke

    You know…dissecting all of your works as I so often do, I am apt to believe that When David Heard is, though beautiful and complex, the most emotionally raw piece you've ever written. I don't conjure images of reserved sadness, but instead takes me from the wimpering, sobbing moments of disbelief to the longing, suffering realization of what just happened and ultimately to the wails and cries of the purest, most basic animal parental instinct feelings that gush at the loss of a child. At one point I'd wanted to find out just what the devil you'd experienced in life to communicate this pain so vividly. This is the first work I ever heard from you and the first time I heard it before hearing the words themselves, I knew the song sung of great, insurmountable sorrow and death. Lauridsen is AMAZING, yes, and it is still endearing to know that after all this time, this piece can still move you, the writer, so profoundly. Your professor at Juilliard also did a similar piece, did he not? Did it have influence or bearing on you writing When David Heard?

  • Skyler Wixom

    You are by far my favorite composer. I am a very young musician, studying to be a composer. I have to say, I can tell you are definately an inspired person. When David Heard moves me to tears. The way you express the agony that David feels is perfect. Where do you get your inspiration? Are there any tips you can give be on composing music? I'd love to hear back from you.

  • http://www.myspace.com/rob256 Rob Henderson

    OK Whitacre, listen up! I'm getting tired of not finding anything when I search for Paradise Lost on iTunes. I think I speak for most of your fans when I say we wanna hear the show! I hate living in Alabama because nothing big goes on down here. For those of us who couldn't go see the show, we want to know what it was like. Kick it into high gear man! We're waitin for ya.

    BTW, I love Her Sacred Spirit Soars… It gives me chills every time I hear it. I haven't heard a bad piece from you yet, so keep churnin em out.

  • Tessy

    Haha, I have to mention that I'm listening to October right now, celebrating the fact that it's now October! :) Personally I think this piece sounds better than just "good". ;) It always connects with me for some reason, no matter how many times I've listened to it.

    Beautiful.

  • Aubrey

    When i heard this piece, I was absolutely overwhelmed. Choral music is one of my favorite styles to listen to. If, done right, a piece of music can change lives in ways that cannot be achieved otherwise. Your music, especially this piece, takes me somewhere else. I glimpsed the face of God in the clashing chords that accompanied the words. The music you write, which no doubt comes from your soul, has changed me. I thank you, and I thank God for the gift he gave you.

  • Sam Reinhard

    When David Heard is the most beautiful piece I have ever heard. My friend and I spent weeks arranging it for a brass ensemble. I am so in love with that piece. Eric you are the most influential artist at this time. Im only 17 but you inspire me to be more than who I am :]

  • Oliver

    Is it true that "When David heard" was composed for a friend of yours whose son had died? Best, Oliver

About Eric

Eric Whitacre is one of the most popular and performed composers of our time, a distinguished conductor, broadcaster and public speaker. His first album as both composer and conductor on Decca/Universal, Light & Gold, won a Grammy® in 2012, reaped unanimous five star reviews and became the no. 1 classical album in the US and UK charts within a week of release... full bio